Many states are impos­ing new and often oner­ous “user fees” on indi­vidu­als with crim­inal convic­­tions. Yet far from being easy money, these fees impose severe – and often hidden – costs on com­munit­ies, taxpay­ers, and indi­gent people convicted of crimes. They create new paths to prison for those unable to pay their debts and make it harder to find employ­ment and hous­ing as well to meet child support oblig­a­tions.

This report exam­ines prac­tices in the fifteen states with the highest prison popu­la­tions, which to­gether account for more than 60 percent of all state crim­inal filings. We focused primar­ily on the prolif­er­a­tion of “user fees, ” finan­cial oblig­a­tions imposed not for any tradi­tional crim­inal justice purpose such as punish­ment, deterrence, or rehab­il­it­a­tion but rather to fund tight state budgets.

Across the board, we found that states are intro­du­cing new user fees, rais­ing the dollar amounts of exist­ing fees, and intensi­fy­ing the collec­tion of fees and other forms of crim­inal justice debt such as fines and resti­tu­tion. But in the rush to collect, made all the more intense by the fiscal crises in many states, no one is consid­er­ing the ways in which the result­ing debt can under­mine reentry prospects, pave the way back to prison or jail, and result in yet more costs to the public.

Document Type


Publication Date



Brennan Center for Justice



Included in

Law Commons